Scarlet Penny Pie Baker

Pies, Desserts and Party Platters

Pie
$22.00
Fruit, Cream or Savory Pies. Call or email for flavors and fillings.
Fruit Crisps
$20.00
Your choice of fruit baked with a oooey gooey crispy crumble topping. Comes in small (serves 8) or large (serves12).
Cheesecake
$25.00
New York Style or any flavor you can dream up!
Bread Pudding
$18.00
Cinnamon Raisin, Butter Pecan, Chocolate Chunk or Apple cinnamon.
Mini Desserts
$18.00
Variety of mousses, lemon berry trifle, strawberry shortcake, chocolate caramel crumble
Mini Tarts
$24.00
Two bite tarts boxed up in dozens and perfect for gift giving to neighbors, friend, clients and coworkers!
Quiche
$18.00
Traditional Lorraine, or try sundried tomato and feta or veggie quiche made fresh in a flakey, buttery crust for breakfast, brunch, dinner or whenever!

Testimonials

a year ago

I thought this place was an actual shop. Drove to the location because the hours listed showed it was still open. It was a residential neighborhood. I called the number and Patty was happy to make a mixed berry crisp for the next day by noon. Fast forward & I forgot about picking up my order because I was hanging out with a friend. I received a text reminder. Payment was simple due to an acceptance of several different cash apps. My crisp looked very professionally made and ended up tasting as delicious as it looked. I warmed it and put a bit of ice cream on top. The only disappointing aspect was her website mentioned cinnamon ice cream as a possible topping with her pies & crisps, but she doesn’t have any. 😉 I can’t find it anywhere. I have had it before while traveling and agree that it would be delicious with her home baked goods. I will be recommending this local business to friends.

- Victoria M

9 months ago

I wanted a butterscotch pie for my 59th birthday and contacted Patty to see if she offered it and she did. Payment was easy through a cash app. My wife picked the pie up when we wanted it. The pie was so delicious and reminded me of the pies my grandmother made when I was a kid. Light meringue on top and a delicious light crust. The butterscotch filling was so good. Luckily I got to eat all but one slice because my wife doesn’t like butterscotch like me! Extremely pleased with the product and overall experience with Patty and will definitely be buying more sweet treats from her in the future.

- Tom Z

a year ago

My son wanted pies for his wedding rather than a groom's cake. Patty baked and delivered pies in four different flavors. They were all visually pretty, nicely boxed, and delicious. The lattice topped peach was not too sweet, had beautiful dough details and was perfect with a little vanilla ice cream. My younger son said the pumpkin was great with a perfect crust. The mother of the bride couldn't believe how much of the mixed berry pie the groom was eating; but I was not surprised at all! That was his favorite!

- Donna H

Hand-made, fresh, delicious!

All of my pies and desserts are hand made. Fresh, hand mixed crust that’s light, buttery and flakey filled with all natural creams or fruits. Mousses are mixed with fresh cream and no imitation flavors, with locally sourced eggs that are only hours old. Truly scratch made sweets like your grandma made ( or wished she could!).